New Proposed Regulations Concerning Valuation Discounts
Proposed tax regulations issued on August 2, 2016 could eliminate or radically reduce the availability of valuation discounts in connection with the transfer of interests in closely held entities to family members. These new regulations are sometimes referred to as the "proposed Section 2704 Regulations," after the section of the Internal Revenue Code to which they relate. The proposed regulations came as some surprise: although new regulations were widely expected, many estate planning professionals predicted that the regulations would impose an upper limit on the size of discounts for federal transfer tax purposes. Instead, the proposed regulations appear to wipe out most valuation discounts in the family context altogether. The proposed regulations may go into effect as early as the end of the year, and accordingly, clients considering transfers of interests in a family-controlled entity (whether an operating business, holding company, vacation home or other asset) should contact us promptly.
The ability to apply valuation discounts to reflect lack of control or ready marketability of a transferred asset has been a bedrock principle of fundamental estate planning for decades. For example, an individual might own a closely held business worth $100 million. Prior to the proposed regulations taking effect, if the individual transfers, say, a 30 percent interest in the business to her child, an appraiser likely would opine that the value of the gift is not $30 million (i.e., 30 percent of $100 million). Instead, the appraiser would apply discounts to reflect the fact that the asset transferred is a minority interest that is not traded on an established exchange. If the appraiser were to conclude that a 33 percent valuation discount should be applied, the value of the gifted property for transfer tax purposes would be only $20 million. As estate planners often liked to say, $10 million of value was made to "disappear" from the transfer tax system, saving the family $4 million of tax (assuming a 40 percent estate tax rate). The proposed Section 2704 Regulations provide that nearly all of the factors historically relied upon to achieve these valuation discounts must be disregarded in the family context, in effect abolishing many of the discounts currently available.
It may be possible to "lock in" discounts by effectuating gifts of interests in closely held entities before the regulations come into effect. If you would like to consider such planning - or if you have questions about the proposed Section 2704 Regulations - don't hesitate to contact your Wiggin and Dana attorney.